FP&A Software Selection Services | Paul Barnhurst — The FP&A Guy
Professional Services

FP&A Software Selection Services

Navigate the complex FP&A software selection process with confidence. Impartial, expert guidance from requirements gathering through vendor selection.

Paul Barnhurst — The FP&A Guy
Paul Barnhurst
The FP&A Guy — Software Selection Advisor
250+ vendor conversations · 100+ FP&A tool demos · CFI course author
Schedule a Consultation

Why You Need an Expert Guide

The FP&A software market has exploded—with over 100 tools available and many founded in the last few years, choosing the wrong platform is costly.

🔍

A Crowded Market

One of the biggest barrier to adopting FP&A tools is a lack of awareness about what's available. With 100+ tools spanning spreadsheet add-ins, web apps, BI-based planners, and enterprise platforms, narrowing the field without expert guidance wastes months.
⚠️

Many Projects Fail

Software projects fail due to poor planning, unclear requirements, resistance to change, and trying to do everything at once. A structured selection process dramatically improves your odds of a successful outcome.
🎯

Impartial Expertise

I'm not affiliated with any vendor. My sole focus is matching your organization's unique requirements—size, industry, processes, and growth trajectory—with the right tool for today and 3–5 years from now.

What I Bring to Your Selection Process

📋

Requirements Discovery

I use a structured intake questionnaire covering 25+ key areas—from your business profile and pain points to integration needs and planning processes—to build a complete picture before evaluating a single vendor.
📊

Market Segmentation

I segment the market by functionality, industry focus, company size, and tool type to create a tailored shortlist. Whether you're an SMB under $100M or an enterprise with 1B+ in revenue, I know who fits.
📝

RFP Development & Management

From drafting the RFP through vendor evaluation and scoring, I guide the entire process. The process includes sample templates you can use to assist with the RFP and vendor evaluation process.
🤝

Vendor Evaluation & Negotiation

I help ensure you evaluate vendors against your requirements—not against each other—and support contract negotiation.
🚀

Vendor Connections

I have relationships with many of the software vendors. I can connect you with the vendor to ensure you receive top-notch support from the software vendors throughout the process.
💡

Future-Proof Planning

I ensure you don't select software that only meets today's needs. We evaluate your growth trajectory, M&A plans, and evolving requirements so your investment scales with your business over 3–5 years.

How the Engagement Works

A proven, structured approach that keeps you in the driver's seat while leveraging my deep market knowledge.

1

Understand Your Business

I start with my structured 25-question intake to deeply understand your operations, reporting and planning processes, team structure, pain points, and vision for your FP&A function.

2

Define Requirements & Problem Statement

Together we craft a clear problem statement, define what success looks like, categorize requirements as mandatory, nice-to-have, or luxury, and scope the project with realistic phasing.

3

Build Your Shortlist

Using my knowledge of the tools, I segment the market by your size, industry, functionality needs, and preferred tool type to produce a curated shortlist of 3–5 vendors that genuinely fit.

4

RFP Process

I provide support as you prepare the RFP, and keep momentum going throughout the evaluation phase.

5

Evaluate & Select

Using a weighted scoring framework, you evaluate each vendor against your requirements and I provide support throughout the process. Ensuring you are considering all aspects of selection.

My 25-Question Vendor Assessment

Before I recommend a single tool, I need to understand your business. Here's a sample of the questions I ask to build your vendor shortlist.

1 Brief description of your business and industry
2 Number of legal entities and countries of operation
3 Employee headcount and revenue estimate
4 Growth trajectory and 3–5 year revenue targets
5 What success looks like for the implementation
6 Biggest challenges and pain points to solve
7 All FP&A processes you plan to use software for
8 Revenue, expense, and CapEx planning methods
9 Current systems: ERP, HR, CRM, BI, and data warehouse
10 Level of spreadsheet integration needed
11 Planning detail level and forecast cycle frequency
12 Budget estimate and deployment preferences

Why This Matters: Free resources exist for identifying FP&A systems, but a curated, personalized assessment connects the dots between your specific needs and the tools available—saving you months of research and reducing the risk of selecting the wrong platform.

Client Testimonial

Paul's support during our FP&A system selection process was truly a game changer. His expertise and guidance not only elevated our professionalism but also gave me the confidence to run a thorough and well-structured RFP process. Thanks to Paul, I felt reassured that, after selecting our partner, there was no post-purchase dissonance or second-guessing—only certainty in our decision.

Understand Our Business

Paul took the time to deeply understand our operations, reporting and planning processes, team structure, and vision for our FP&A function. Using this knowledge, he challenged me and my team to develop business requirements that directly addressed the challenges our company was facing. His ability to connect the dots between our needs and the tools available was invaluable.

Momentum and Engagement

The RFP process can be as rewarding as you make it, and Paul ensured it was both effective and enjoyable. His constant availability for check-ins—whether with me or my team—kept the momentum going. This was crucial, given our limited resources. Paul's efforts also helped keep the vendors engaged throughout, ensuring that neither side lost focus or interest, which can be critical in decision-making.

Tailored and Impartial Guidance

While free resources exist for identifying FP&A systems, Paul brought a curated approach that felt personalized to our unique business requirements. There was no bias in the process—my team remained in the driver's seat from start to finish, with Paul collaborating as a trusted advisor. His priority was for us to arrive at a decision based on our own merits, which is why we are so thrilled with both the partner we selected and the process we followed.

Chris Pawluk
Chris Pawluk
FP&A Software Selection Client

Frequently Asked Questions

How do you remain impartial if you know all the vendors?

I have no financial relationship with any FP&A software vendor. I don't receive referral fees or commissions. My only client is you, and my priority is helping your team arrive at the right decision on your own merits.

What size companies do you work with?

I work across the full spectrum—from SMBs under 500 employees and $100M revenue through mid-market (up to 5,000 employees) to large enterprises with $1B+ revenue. The market segmentation and shortlist I build is tailored specifically to your company's size and growth trajectory.

How long does the selection process take?

A typical engagement runs 8–16 weeks from initial intake through vendor selection, depending on your internal timelines, team availability, and the number of vendors evaluated. I build in buffer time for the unexpected and break the process into manageable phases.

What if we've already started evaluating vendors?

I can jump into your process at any stage. Whether you need help refining your shortlist, structuring your RFP, managing demos, or making the final decision, I'll adapt to wherever you are in the journey.

Do you help with implementation too?

My primary focus is selection, but I make myself available as a sounding board throughout the implementation process.

What does a typical budget look like for FP&A software?

Pricing varies widely. Small market tools range from $150–$2K/month with up to $20K implementation. Mid-market tools run $2K–$10K/month with $20K–$100K implementation. Enterprise solutions can be $100K–$250K+/month with $100K–$1M+ implementation. I help you understand the full total cost of ownership, including hidden costs like data migration and change management.

© 2025 The FP&A Guy. All rights reserved.