When AI Does the Analysis, What Makes FP&A Valuable? with Polina Nyer

In this episode of FP&A Unlocked, host Paul Barnhurst sits down with Polina Nyer to explore the evolution of the Finance function and what it really means to transform it. The conversation looks beyond AI as a technology trend to examine how Finance can rethink its operating model, redesign processes, and become a more strategic partner to the business.

Polina Nyer is a Senior FP&A Lead at HP Inc., where she works at the intersection of finance, strategy, and transformation. With a background in FP&A, financial planning, and business transformation, she focuses on turning Finance from a reporting function into a more strategic, data-driven business partner.

Expect to Learn:

  • How Finance can better align its operating model with business needs.

  • Why transforming processes matters more than simply automating them.

  • How FP&A can move from reporting to decision support.

  • Which skills will matter most for finance professionals in the age of AI.

  • Why Finance Transformation should be an ongoing process.


Here are a few relevant quotes from the episode:

  • “Our job isn't simply to explain the numbers, but it's to help the business make better decisions.” - Polina Nyer

  • “We need to make it in a way that finance teams are bettering themselves every day.” - Polina Nyer


Polina emphasizes that Finance Transformation is not a one-time project but an ongoing process of improvement. By combining financial expertise, technology, and human judgment, finance professionals can make better decisions, strengthen business partnerships, and create greater value.


Follow Polina:


Pigment CTA:
Pigment is an AI business planning and performance management platform helping teams across finance, sales, supply chain, and other business functions at companies like Unilever, Snowflake, and Anthropic anticipate change, plan ahead, and act with confidence.

Try Pigment for free for 14 days: https://www.pigment.com/trial/sign-up?utm_source=podcast&utm_medium=paid_other&utm_campaign=influencer&utm_content_1=free-trial&utm_term=paul-barnhurst

Disclosure: Portions of this episode (such as the introduction or promotional segments) use AI-generated voice narration produced under human editorial review.

Earn Your CPE Credit
For CPE credit, please go to earmarkcpe.com, listen to the episode, download the app, answer a few questions, and earn your CPE certification. To earn education credits for the FPAC Certificate, take the quiz on Earmark and contact Paul Barnhurst for further details.

In Today's Episode:

[00:00] - Introduction
[03:13] - What Defines Great FP&A?
[06:25] - Using Technology and AI to Improve FP&A
[10:34] - Continuous Finance Transformation
[18:11] - Rethinking Finance Processes with AI
[22:42] - Beyond AI-Generated Analysis
[27:27] - Essential FP&A Skills in the Age of AI
[35:10] - Helping Finance Teams Adapt to AI
[41:13] - Designing the Finance Function of the Future
[46:56] - No.1 Technical Skill for FP&A
[51:42] - Volunteering and Giving Back 

Full Show Transcript: 

[00:35] Paul Barnhurst: Are you tired of being seen as just a spreadsheet person while others get a seat at the table? Well then, welcome to FP&A Unlocked, where finance meets strategy. I'm your host, Paul Barnhurst, aka the FP&A Guy. Each week we bring you conversations and practical advice from thought leaders, industry experts, and practitioners who are reshaping the role of FP&A in today's business world. And together we'll uncover strategies and experiences to help you separate good FP&A professionals from great ones, helping you elevate your career and drive strategic impact. Today's guest is Polina Nyer. Polina, welcome to the show.


[01:14] Polina Nyer: Hi, thanks for having me.


[01:15] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah, excited to have you. I know we had an opportunity to chat ahead of time, and I'm really excited to get into your background. I think you have a fascinating background, so thanks again for carving out some time for us.


[01:25] Polina Nyer: Great. Yeah, I'm very happy to be here. Excited for our conversation.


[01:29] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah, so a little bit about Polina's background. She's a Senior FP&A Lead at HP Inc. She works at the intersection of finance, strategy, and transformation. So there are a lot of places we can go. She has a background in FP&A, financial planning, and business transformation, and she's focused on turning finance from a reporting function, what I used to call FP&R, financial planning and reporting, because that's what it was when I started my career it felt like, into a more strategic, data-driven business partner. She is passionate about how technology, particularly AI, is changing the way finance teams operate, make decisions, and create value. She has spoken at industry events including IMA26, RISE Women's Leadership Conference, and Finance Alliance FP&A Summit, where she has shared practical approaches to applying AI in finance and leading transformation. She also has her CMA and CSCA. And so love the background. I'm going to start with this question.


[02:33] Paul Barnhurst: We ask every guest this. How would you define great FP&A?


[02:38] Polina Nyer: Oh, that's a great question. And when I was preparing for this podcast, I went back and heard some of the answers and it's very interesting how each professional interprets this question. And I would say for me, great FP&A starts with understanding that our job isn't simply to explain the numbers, but it's to help the business make better decisions. And sometimes that sounds like a given, but historically, this has not been the case. And I think a good indication of knowing whether the FP&A function is seen as a business partner is whether the business leaders come to us first before they make a decision rather than coming to us afterwards to understand what would be the financial impact of the decision that they already made without us. So this all, I think, comes from connecting the results to what is happening in the business. Why is it happening?


[03:39] Polina Nyer: What are the drivers? And I'm sure we're going to talk about this a lot, but understanding the operations and the business drivers behind the numbers is a big portion of the work that we do and hopefully we'll do more as AI steps into our daily lives. So to be a good business partner, we need to have a lot of trust. The business needs to believe in us, which means credibility, and we need to be ready to ask difficult questions because they need to be challenged and we need to explain the trade-offs of their decisions. So interesting to see how all of this evolves with AI.


[04:19] Paul Barnhurst: It definitely will be. I'm excited to see how things evolve, but there's two things I really love that you said there. One, they want us in the room when the decision's made. They don't come to us after and ask us, "Hey, how does this impact us?" That's a sign you're doing something right. And the second one you said, which rarely do FP&A professionals say, but I've heard several business people say, is we need to challenge them. They often say when they think of great FP&A, they want to be challenged, but rarely do I hear an FP&A person say, "We need to challenge the business." So I really love that answer because I think the business wants that, especially if the business looks to finance an FP&A as a resource that can help them. They want to be challenged because none of us are going to make the right answer all the time.


[05:10] Paul Barnhurst: We're all going to make suboptimal decisions on our own at some point.


[05:13] Polina Nyer: Yeah, completely agree. I think ultimately if we can be measured by not the reports that we produced, but the number of decisions we influenced, this would be the next step, the next era of FP&A.


[05:27] Paul Barnhurst: Agree. The more and more we can go into how are we helping them make better decisions. We can't make the decisions ourselves, so it's how are we influencing the business to address the most important things? So I'm curious, obviously you've done a lot of FP&A, but you're very big in technology. How did you become interested in technology, especially as it relates to finance and FP&A?


[05:50] Polina Nyer: Yeah, I would admit I'm not a technology geek, so I do not approach technology in FP&A and finance from the perspective of the technology itself, but it's more about finding better ways to work, especially in finance. Historically, we've been spending so much time collecting the data, reconciling the data, building the model, building the deck, preparing the reports. And this actually relates to a story from me growing up. My mom, she would always say this phrase of achieving things with minimum effort, maximum result, which has stuck with me. And I do apply it to my job as well because it's often about how much we can do, spending less time preparing and analyzing and more time understanding the business so then we can make this step of influencing the decisions. And my interest in AI actually was on a very practical use cases. I often, I try to protect time within my day, even though we are all very busy, to experiment with it and just try to solve, maybe not solve, but improve things that I already do on a daily basis.


[07:14] Polina Nyer: And also this goes to not only for me personally, but making sure that people around me have the time to do the same. And when you start experimenting more and more, I feel like you see that the opportunity goes beyond writing a better formula, for example, or producing the same report that you used to produce but more quickly. It opens doors. For example, scenario analysis I have been experimenting with a lot. And here I have an example, I'm sure you have experienced that too. In a few rows back, I was doing a lot of best-, middle-, and worst-case scenarios and we would always limit them to those. It will be three scenarios and the assumptions would vary based on these exceptionally good or exceptionally bad scenarios and the one that you kind of believed in. And now with AI, you can have endless scenarios and you can change variables as many times and as much as you want and in as many of the variables as you want.


[08:18] Polina Nyer: And this, for example, has really opened doors to investigate the business and see what is a plausible decision moving forward. So it is a personal passion and at the same time solving the problem at work. And because I'm at FP&A, I can approach a question from a perspective of someone who understands the practical reality of, for example, forecasting and budgeting and have suffered through the pain points of those processes and how can we do better?


[08:54] Paul Barnhurst: I like the point you made of it's not that you're on the cutting edge of technology or technology for technology's sake. It's the example you shared of your mother, basically of how can we work smarter, right? Work less, maximize efficiency. And so it's always AI helps us do that, helps to fulfill that. And so I like the way you put that. And I know one thing you've worked a lot on is you've worked a lot on transformation projects. I know you've been an FP&A, you've been on the tech side transformation, which again is all about helping using technology to help us do better. But I have a question. Something that I've always been bothered by is just even the phrase finance transformations. It implies that when the project is done, something has been transformed, which means it's kind of completely changed if you think of what a transformation is.


[09:44] Paul Barnhurst: When you think of an animal, a caterpillar transforms into a butterfly. But the reality is it's much more a continuous change. In my opinion, there isn't a transformation that's occurred. So I'd love to just get your thoughts on that idea and how you think about, especially with AI coming, how do you think about transformation in finance?


[10:03] Polina Nyer: Yeah, I really like the example that you gave of transforming and almost implying of a before and after case scenario, which we all know it's just not the reality of the world. The technology that we operate in and the business, they keep evolving. So I completely agree. And I think this is one of those jargon terminology problem that we have in our field. And also I think calling it a project also implies this end state that maybe go live of the tool can be considered the end state of a transformation, but it's really more of a process and a continuous journey. So I completely agree with you on that point. And from one state to another should not be a measure for success. So the biggest transformation project that I worked on was exactly like that. It had an end date. It was a three-year project.


[11:03] Polina Nyer: It is true that there was a lot of redesigning on top of introducing a new tool. However, I want to see transformation in a way of being driven more by the employees. I feel like, especially in big companies, there is a lot of financial professionals and FP&As being almost like the recipients of transformation rather than driving transformation. And ultimately the people who observe the inefficiencies in tools and processes are often the people who use those tools and processes every day. So having them not only how they would always have a change champion or a transformation champion, not only having them as champion, but having them truly drive the definition of what the better process or the better system would be, I think would ultimately really improve the outcome of those transformation efforts in any size company and in any industry. And I also think it requires a different mindset from the leadership because instead of treating the improvement as something that happens every few years, which is what I have observed in my company, and also I think what most companies do is we would transform, then we would pause in this end state, and then we will transform again in a few years.


[12:30] Polina Nyer: We need to make it in a way that finance teams are bettering themselves every day. And I know it is hard for you. Again, it comes back to capacity. How do you do your job, but also you improve what you're doing every day on a daily basis. But I think a good practice for everyone to try is just when you do something at work, ask yourself, why am I doing this? You would be surprised how many times, especially if you're more junior and somebody passes you a task and you're like, okay, this is my responsibility now and I start doing it, pausing and asking this question of why am I doing this could really make a difference. And then if success is not measured by whether what was produced before continues to be produced now, we can then, with this help of leadership, defining what success matters in a different terms, we can then move on from having to look at it as a defined project timeline.


[13:31] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. And there's a lot we could unpack there. I think first you make a great point. There are going to be defined projects in the sense that there's going to be go live dates and there's going to be when things wrap up, but you also need to figure out how do we make sure there's that mindset of continuous process improvement and there's the recognition that just because we go live doesn't mean a transformation has occurred in the sense of, okay, we've reached a new state, now we just operate this for a while and then when it comes time, we'll transform again. It's more of, okay, how do we now continue to improve? We got the new tool. Are we making better decisions? How do we take to the next level? So I really like that you mentioned that. I think that's what we're all trying to figure out with AI because as soon as you think you've done a transformation with AI, the models, the tools have all changed and what you can do is changed again, what's capable.


[14:25] Paul Barnhurst: And so I mean, if we look over the last three years, it's moved incredibly fast. The example I give, and I don't know if you ever remember seeing it, three or four years ago when they showed how Will Smith ate spaghetti with AI in his -


[14:38] Polina Nyer: That's the benchmark of AI.


[14:40] Paul Barnhurst: And look at a video now, and you can barely tell. You may not even be able to tell that it's not him. FP&A Guy here, and I want to share a brief message from our sponsor. The world doesn't operate on a quarterly planning cycle, so why should your business meet Pigment, the AI planning platform moving companies from static forecasts to continuous intelligent decision-making? With AI agents that monitor performance, simulate scenarios, and flag risks, Pigment helps teams respond to change before it becomes a problem. From finance to sales, supply chain, and more, companies like Uber, Snowflake, and Unilever use Pigment to run their business at the speed of change. See how and try it for free at pigment.com. That's pigment.com.


[15:33] Polina Nyer: Yeah. And what you said about the go live date, I actually, it's interesting what I have experienced with transformation is that often, I don't want to say failure, but the most problems actually appear after that go-live date and with adoption. And I think we have all gone through, I think people would relate to this situation of having the new tool and then you have the separate Excel on the side doing the exact same thing that you were doing before, almost like working around the new process. Or also another example that I have to share that I have experienced is sunsetting an ERP system and then implementing another one. And then you have users using the old one until literally the hour until it sunsets. That's not a good sign and it really should point your attention to why is this happening?


[16:28] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. And you make a great point of a lot of the pain is once you go live because, oh, that process didn't quite work as planned. Oh, we didn't realize about this. We didn't do a good enough job training so-and-so. I remember joining a company for the first month live on a new ERP. So I'm a brand new employee, try to try things back to our budget and it was just a mess. I mean, there were a lot of conversations, things being booked wrong by the business because they didn't understand the new PO process that went with the ERP rollout. We also brought all the accounting people together. So we went to a shared service center versus individual businesses, got them all trained, then they switched ERPs. So you had all new people for the most part and a whole new system. And it was, I remember that first month, go live was not where the pain was.


[17:22] Polina Nyer: Yeah. I think that's often the case.


[17:24] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. I know I'm not alone in that, but that's my experience to just exactly what you're talking about. It's a real pain point. Yeah, I'd love to get a little bit of your thought. Obviously, AI is able to make existing processes faster. So is that where we should focus on making things faster? Do we need to fundamentally rethink our processes to get the most out of AI? How should we think about processes with AI?


[17:50] Polina Nyer: I think that's a great question and very diplomatically, I would say we need to do both. There is a very big value from having your work done faster. We shouldn't dismiss that quick wins of being able to accelerate the redundant manual work that all of us perform on a regular basis. And for me, the biggest one is PowerPoint. I feel like many companies spend so much time in designing slides and now it is, I don't know what the percentage of time saved it is, but it is I'm sure significant. There are many, many areas in reporting where we can use that as well. But if we stop there with just simply automation and raising productivity, we are missing a big chunk of the value of the new technology. And also we are preserving old ways of working. And if you think about just, let's say variance analysis, because we do it all the time, we now can use AI for the majority of it, for collecting the results, identifying the variances, and then even writing up the commentary, the initial draft of commentary of why something moved.


[19:13] Polina Nyer: However, the value, and I have heard many people on the podcast say this, and we I'm sure are going to continue hearing that for years to come, that the value of us remains the judgment, what comes after the analysis is produced. And one thing I think is important for us to keep in mind is that not every process needs to necessarily be reinvented. There will be processes inside the organization that already work well, and we shouldn't forget the very core of finance, like financial controls, for example, governance, guardrails, because they all exist for a very, very good reason. And the goal is not to automate everything without discriminating, but it's more to remove or accelerate the necessary work so then we can do other things that add more value. And I'm sure we're going to touch upon this more. But to circle back, I would say yes on speeding up redundant manual work and then definitely yes on going a step further and using AI for transforming the way that we work on a daily basis.


[20:34] Paul Barnhurst: Makes a lot of sense. I think the one I've heard a lot of people is if all you're getting at is efficiency out of AI, you're falling well short. And if you can get your data stuff aligned, your process is right, it can help you make better decisions. As you've mentioned, we still have to own it. We have to bring our human judgment. As one person I know said, now that we can basically ask any question we want, it's even more important that we know how to ask the right questions and know if we have the right answer than it's ever been.


[21:07] Polina Nyer: That's well said. And I think exactly what you said, automation and productivity does not equal value.


[21:15] Paul Barnhurst: We've all automated something that later on we realized nobody was using.


[21:20] Polina Nyer: Guilty of that too.


[21:22] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. I mean, I could admit I built more than one report or I think it's cool to come to find out nobody's using it and like, okay, why did I spend all that time?


[21:32] Polina Nyer: Yeah. Well, actually let me share this with because yesterday I killed one report, so here we go.


[21:41] Paul Barnhurst: Good. I like it. So I take it nobody was using it.


[21:45] Polina Nyer: Yep. Well, it took me, I don't even want to know how long they have not been using it. I'm not going to go there, but it's gone now.


[21:54] Paul Barnhurst: No. Yeah. If you don't have one of those stories, you haven't worked in FP&A long enough. All right. I'm curious as AI and tech do more and more of the analysis, right? It's really good. I don't think people realize if they haven't used it lately, how good it's got at a lot of simple tasks, how clean and polished it can look with things. And if we give it good context so we're getting right numbers, how do we ensure we're adding value in the work we do if most of the analysis is being done by AI?


[22:28] Polina Nyer: Yes. Here I think we have a great opportunity because we have spent a big chunk of our time producing that analysis, and now we have an opportunity to shift that time to interpreting the analysis and challenging the assumptions behind it. And then again, reaching our ultimate goal of helping the business decide what are they going to do about this analysis. And I think these are different levels having, for example, I'll go back to our example with the variances. Having an explanation automatically like AI would, for example, create doesn't necessarily mean that it understands the business context, that it knows all of the assumptions or that it knows what the management should do. So these are different layers of us using AI and improving. But I think we also need to be, this is directly to your question, what can we do? And I will go back to what I said in the beginning, we need to be very comfortable challenging the business.


[23:35] Polina Nyer: Sometimes the numbers tell us that a plan isn't realistic and we need to present some other options, and those options always have trade-offs. So if we can spend time with the business helping them understand what those trade-offs are, they can make a more informed decision and ultimately everybody wins in the organization and exactly this is how we win our seat at the table to be involved in these kinds of conversations before the decision is made. But AI can help us here too. For example, it can help us with what the possibilities are. Of course, we can filter the options afterwards and we should do that every single time, but it does stimulate the thinking of where we can potentially go. Another area I think we can focus on more is to be a little more forward looking. We have been historically, I think, doing a lot of backward looking postmortem sort of analysis.


[24:40] Polina Nyer: And even if I think back when I started over a decade ago, how long, for example, a close cycle was compared to now, it has improved a lot, but at the same time, you're closing the books of the month that has passed.


[25:01] Polina Nyer: I work in a publicly traded company. It is happening every month and it's happening every quarter. So if we can use AI for some of those very core FP&A finance activities, and then we can explore more of the scenarios or for example, instead of us, once we close the books, investigate something that went wrong, oh, we gave more discounts, for example, that we planned to, we can maybe do that as the moment goes so that we can do something about it. And I don't think all these things are going to happen automatically. We all need to develop these skills of working differently and also to build the expectations within the organizations that we want to influence decisions and not just report on what has happened. And I think here it really depends on the organization. There are some organizations that do consider finance a strategic business partner.


[26:01] Polina Nyer: It's more like it's a spectrum. Some are closer to the decisions and some are further away. And the organizations that are further away have a even bigger opportunity to use AI to get closer to the decision.


[26:16] Paul Barnhurst: No, I totally agree to help them get closer to the decision. So you've talked a lot there, and what I'm curious is, obviously AI can help us get closer to the business. We need to make sure we're pushing the business forward. You mentioned the example of getting to the point we're not ever getting better at being forward looking during the time, the operational data versus backward looking. We've all seen it where, okay, we've closed the book, your example, why did discounts happen? So as we continue to use AI more as automation, things get quicker, we get better, we're closing the book sooner. How does the skills we need change? How do you see that kind of changing? What advice would you give to people? Because I think everybody to a certain extent is trying to say, how do I stay relevant in this new world?


[27:10] Polina Nyer: This is a question that I get asked a lot, and it's interesting. Different people in different stages of their career more or less worried about the skills that remain. I feel like more junior people entering the professions are less worried about this because they don't really know what was expected until now, so they just get what's available and run with it. Whereas I think the most concerned people are my mid-career sort of very strategic individual contributors or mid-management. So I would say the finance fundamentals are still very, very important. And I would argue that they might even be even more important now that we have AI. And this goes back to what you said, that understanding the accounting and the financial modeling logic behind something that AI presents may be exactly the key to being able to tell whether the answer is good or bad, or even whether the answer is right versus wrong.


[28:24] Polina Nyer: These remain fundamental, the finance fundamentals. And at the same time, we need to be very comfortable using technology. I know some of us are, others not so much, but there is no escape. We have to be, and I'm sure we are all experiencing this, the little pop-up on your whichever AI system you're using is like, oh, explore this new thing, new feature that we just released. And I feel like the little pop-up is there almost every other day. Maybe do click on it instead of trying to shut it down every time. But another thing that we would need to develop or improve is just articulating the problem and giving the context clearly. And I think this goes beyond prompting, but just being able to clear your thoughts and explain what you're trying to ask better can lead to much better outcomes. And I think this leads into this whole human, let's say human skills, the critical thinking, curiosity, being able to communicate and ultimately being able to influence.


[29:38] Polina Nyer: And one thing I would add here, I feel there is a little bit of a fatigue happening in our profession where things are changing so rapidly and people are like, "Well, this is great. Now I have this Copilot, ChatGPT, Gemini, and now I finally learned how to probe the thing." And now there are seven... Other features and skills and link the skills together. And it is just very overwhelming. So I also recognize the side of being tired of being curious and motivated. So it really requires us to almost self-motivate to continue keeping up with the change in technology, which requires just another skill of, you want to call it motivation, call it continuous curiosity, but persistence for sure.


[30:33] Paul Barnhurst: FP&A Guy here with another brief message from our sponsor. AI can give you an answer in seconds, but would you bet your business on it? With Pigment, you can. AI agents run on the numbers your whole company agrees on. They model scenarios, flag risks, and update plans with the controls your team needs. That's why Unilever, Uber, and Snowflake plan on Pigment. Pigment, plan with AI you can trust. Learn more at pigment.com. That's pigment.com. Yeah, I like that term of persistence because, yes, fatigue is real, and you have to balance. As I tell people, you don't have to look at every new feature, every new model that comes out and switch your processes and always be on the cutting edge. If things are working well and you're getting great efficiency, okay, but you still need to keep an eye on it. You can't just sit back and be like, all right, I'm in an established state because it's not where AI's at.


[31:33] Paul Barnhurst: I mean, you laugh as I say that, right? And so I think you make a great point there. A couple others that stood out to me is one, you just have to adopt it. You no longer have a choice. If you don't adopt AI, you're killing your career to a certain extent. If you're close to retirement, whatever, there's always exceptions, but as a general rule, you have to embrace it. And so I think that the ship sailed of whether I should embrace it or not. We're at the point you have to embrace it.


[32:02] Polina Nyer: Yeah. Yeah. It's not going anywhere.


[32:05] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. It's like the computer. The computer's not going away. AI is not going away. The internet's not going away. New technology doesn't get put back in the box. So I think that ship for sure has sailed. So I think you made a great point there. And then obviously the human skills, but I think the one I really liked is not just prompting, but how do you articulate and how do you help with process and improving things? Because you got to give AI enough to be able to build a good process. And whether you're doing it or somebody else


[32:36] Polina Nyer: Is


[32:36] Paul Barnhurst: Doing it, it has to be done. And the more


[32:38] Polina Nyer: You


[32:38] Paul Barnhurst: Can learn about it, the more


[32:40] Polina Nyer: You


[32:40] Paul Barnhurst: Can help automate your own processes as you get better at that.


[32:43] Polina Nyer: Yeah, you actually bring a good point here in communication. For me as a non-native English speaker interacting with AI, sometimes I have to pause and be very clear with myself of what I'm trying to articulate. And even things like we talked about the jargon and all of those terms as transformation and what it means and how it could be interpreted. So you do need to take the time to be able to articulate well. And then I hope it's a skill that we will all build over time.


[33:21] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah, it's definitely one I think we're all building. And it's funny, when it first came out, everybody was very focused on writing good prompts. Now you tell AI what you want and it can write a better prompt than you can. That doesn't mean you're getting the right answer. And so now it's learning how context and all the skills and just feels like the goalposts are constantly shifting, as you mentioned, a new thing like how good it is, how you get the most out of it, what tool you use, what's the right model and how do I keep my cost down? And one day it was, we should all be token maxing and then it was all of sudden, wait, that costs a lot. Stop doing that. One day it's like, we all need a prompt well. The next day it's like it's all about context.


[34:02] Paul Barnhurst: So we know now it's all about this harness and agents. Okay, what is it? The fatigue part, it's real. I mean, I'm not in FP&A day-to-day and just I know I use AI obviously, but I also know I need to be a lot more efficient and there's things I can do in my business that I'm not doing and always wondering, okay, am I missing out? Am I generating less revenue than I can? And so I can only imagine being in the business, the pressure that people are feeling around AI. I mean, I'm sure you feel pressure of how do you continue to get better results and be more efficient as you're trying to be on this AI journey.


[34:40] Polina Nyer: Yeah, but I also feel pressure just in my team. Not everybody's equally motivated to learn. And for leaders, this is really a hot topic on the table of you don't want some of your team members to exceed and other to fall behind. So how do you set example by you using it, but also how do you motivate others to experiment? And then the most fundamental thing, and I think we are going to step into talking about this, it's one thing to say, go experiment with AI, but if you also give them workload that they have no time to experiment with AI, then you can have very high expectations.


[35:23] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. Well, and the second part of that is, well, you get a $20 budget, but go experiment. You have to be willing to spend some money. You got to set aside some experimentation budget if you want to get to the end in the sense of you want good processes, good learning. I'm totally with you. It's a real challenge. And we see that in the training I do all the time as you're talking to people and you know people are at totally different points in that journey. And it's a lot like Excel. I love training Excel and I hate training Excel because you got 15 people in a room and one person barely knows what a sum ifs is, and the other person wants you to teach them VBA and you're just like, all right. And the one person's constantly slow down, the other one's go faster.


[36:10] Paul Barnhurst: And I think you're seeing a similar type of thing happening with AI because there's so much to learn and there's so many different places to go that you got the person here that's still, how do I write a good prompt? Oh, you mean I don't have to use Google to do this? And then you have the person over here creating a whole agentic harness. So as a leader, how do you bring everybody along? That's going to change. I think there's some change in strategy of leadership and it's just fascinating to watch. It's a real challenge.


[36:38] Polina Nyer: Have you had other leaders on the podcast that shared that they're dealing with exactly same thing right now?


[36:46] Paul Barnhurst: Not in that way, but I've definitely had more conversations around how do we train people if AI gets better? So I had a great conversation yesterday and I'd love to get your thoughts. We're going to go a little off speed. So it will come out on Financial Modelers Corner. I was interviewing Hillary Smart. She's the only woman to ever win the world championship in modeling. Super smart woman. So just give some background. She's written cases for them and she's working on their training for their company of how they ensure they use AI to speed things up without losing the skills and the ability to own the process. And they're very much known for their trust in modeling. So it's how do we keep all that? And she gave the example and I really like this as far as training employees, real challenge. She goes, "I like to think of it like a flight simulator.


[37:36] Paul Barnhurst: No pilot's put on a plane without a couple hundred hours in a flight simulator." It's like we should be thinking similar with new employees in AI. And what they're doing is she goes, "Now as AI is doing a little bit more, and so some of the more senior may be able to handle more cases, the junior, we're often choosing historic cases to train them on to learn the skills versus them learning on new work." She goes, "Now we can pick." Before somebody may have got eight easy cases and the other new employee got the hardest example of the company and they weren't ready for it. So now we can kind of pick and choose what we're giving them like that flight simulator. And that's how she's thinking of bringing people along is some of those things got automated. And I thought it was a very thoughtful approach, has some cost to it, but at the same time it has some real benefit because there are just some things that are critical that you have to learn.


[38:33] Paul Barnhurst: And if you're not doing it day to day, how do you learn it? So I'd love to get your thoughts, but that's the example in how she shared something thinking about.


[38:40] Polina Nyer: Yeah, it's something I don't necessarily have an answer for you, but it's something I have been thinking about. And again, related to these young professionals that are stepping into this world of finance and FP&A and they will, good for them, hopefully never needs to sit there and do a manual journal entry and then wait for one day or afraid to post in the system in order for them to make sure that it was correct. But you know very well that also digging in the model to find this formula, where it comes from and how it relates. These are not particularly fun things to do, but over time I think we can all agree that they do play an important role in business acumen and just the way that finance connects the dots between the operational drivers results and business outcomes. So I have actually not heard of an example like this of using past experiences to train new people.


[39:44] Polina Nyer: And it does seem like you already have the answer, so that's a good start. And it does seem like a plausible way to train somebody, but of course you will need leadership, as you said, to be able and willing to commit some resources to do that, which would be interesting to see how they take it.


[40:05] Paul Barnhurst: Yeah. I'll be curious to see how it continues to go. I mean, that's what they're starting. And some companies will, some will be like, no way. We'll just hire mid from other places or we'll figure it out. The analyst just has to come up to speed. But it's definitely something we all have to address, and I thought it was a thoughtful, interesting solution. Is it the only one? No. And what the other ones will be, we'll see with time, but it's something we all have to address both in the educational system and as you start your career.


[40:34] Polina Nyer: Yeah. Yeah, agree.


[40:35] Paul Barnhurst: All right. So I'd love to get your thought. You're designing the finance function of the future today. What are you going to change? What are you going to keep the same? How are you thinking about it?


[40:46] Polina Nyer: Yeah. Well, this is related to something we talked about when we were preparing this call. I shared with you that I was working on a zero-based budget exercise, and I think I would actually take that approach where I would start with what are the decisions that needs to be made by the business and the actions that they need to be taken, and then almost work backwards from that rather than starting from where the structure and the processes within the organization are already. So I would like to know, for example, what information do leaders need in order to do their job and how quickly do they need it? What analysis do they need in order to make a decision? If something is automated, where is human judgment important within the journey of a process? And I think if you use an approach like that, we will have to rethink quite a lot about how finance currently operate.


[41:51] Polina Nyer: And I think we would be challenging reporting processes for sure, the way we forecast. And we might remove a lot of unnecessary complexity that I feel like it just accumulates somehow in finance over time. Different steps and reports and approvals keep being added on top. So of course, AI, I would think that would be part of the design of this new FP&A function from the very beginning. Instead of now we have AI on top of something that already exists. If you were to redesign and from scratch, you would obviously include AI from the beginning. But I think it's very important also to acknowledge what shouldn't change, which would be the integrity of our profession, the fact that we are the keepers of very sensitive information, the accountability, the controls that we have in place. Also, the understanding of the numbers that is not given and not everybody in the organization has really the education and the knowledge of understanding the business well.


[43:02] Polina Nyer: So we cannot compromise on those existing principles and we should definitely preserve them. And again, going back to this, almost like an independent challenger role that we have, we need to question things, question the assumptions, question the deal. Why is this deal so important? Why is this client so important? And why are you willing to spend all your budget on lending them, for example, and to provide an independent objective view and perspective when the business is making difficult decisions? Because especially in today's economy, many businesses are facing very, very difficult decisions. And I would say in a new FP&A, the time dedicated to different activities would be shifted in an ideal new FP&A function.


[44:01] Paul Barnhurst: 100%. I mean, history shows 75% of our time is spent on non-value-added activities. A lot of studies they've done. We'd want to flip that. You want at least 80% spent on value-added activities. Very little should be. You're always going to spend some, you're never going to get 100%, but 25%, that's definitely, if you asked that, I can't think of any FP&A person in an ideal scenario that say that's the ideal. We all think we need to be more. So I agree with you. And I loved how you talked about starting from what's the outcomes you want in the business, not starting with the technology. One of my favorite quotes, Hasser Consulting said, "New technology plus old processes equals expensive broken old processes."


[44:49] Polina Nyer: Yeah, very good sage.


[44:51] Paul Barnhurst: And it kind of gets to what you're saying. You got to really rethink everything because in an AI world, would we be doing some of the things we're doing? And the answer more than likely is no, if we redesigned it today.


[45:05] Polina Nyer: Yeah. Oh, this reminds me of last week I spoke at this conference organized by the Finance Alliance, the FP&A Summit, and I met somebody who told me that they work in a startup and their startup does not have email. So I wonder if you have ever -


[45:25] Paul Barnhurst: I haven't heard of that yet, but I could see that with Slack and Teams and video calling and I could see where you do that. I would struggle mightily in that environment. I'm so used to email.


[45:38] Polina Nyer: Yeah, that's what I though, but it was a very interesting perspective. And I had also heard of it before, but I have never met anybody who was experiencing it firsthand. So this was very interesting and this goes exactly directly to the point that you made about non-value activities, which probably email is at least of three in those. And it was interesting to hear, and I think it will be more interesting to see if this company in a few years from now continues not having an email.


[46:11] Paul Barnhurst: It's going to be fascinating to watch. That's really interesting. All right, we're going to move into our, what we call the FP&A section. I'm going to do two questions here, then we're going to do a couple get to know you questions and we'll wrap up. So just a few more minutes. I ask pretty much every guest this question, and I love seeing how the answers have shifted over time as AI has become bigger and bigger. So what is the number one technical skill FP&A professionals need to master?


[46:40] Polina Nyer: Okay. I think people may argue with me whether this is a business technical skill or not, but for me it's business acumen, understanding the drivers, operational and business drivers behind the numbers, what drives the revenues, the cost, the profitability, and how those interact with each other. This goes together with being able to build a very good financial model and the logic behind the business translates into the financial results.


[47:11] Paul Barnhurst: I'm sure some would argue whether it's a technical or but I let you give your answer. I'll leave the guest to argue that. But I do have to put a plug here because it's just too good. I just about two months ago released my course, first course for LinkedIn Learning. It's business acumen for FP&A professionals.


[47:27] Polina Nyer: Oh, great. Yeah.


[47:28] Paul Barnhurst: Course is this very topic you're talking about. How do you connect the strategy and the operational drivers and using frameworks and not speaking jargon and really being a strategic business partner versus just being kind of a traditional backward looking reporting focused FP&A professional. So critical. I totally agree with you. Very important. All right. What about soft skill? What's number one?


[47:54] Polina Nyer: Here I would say the ability to influence through the way that you communicate because I believe you may have the best analysis in the world, but if you cannot communicate what that means and what actions should follow based on your analysis, you're really limiting its impact a lot. And I think this goes beyond presenting well, but it also includes understanding what matters to the other party and then translating that analysis into a conversation that can change their mind.


[48:31] Paul Barnhurst: I've had to learn that lesson several times the hard way. I've fallen short many times. Influencing is not easy, but if you want that seat at the table that we talked at the beginning where you said you want to be in the room before the decision is made, you need to be able to learn how to influence the business in a positive way. Because if you're not doing that, they're like, "Well, why do I need you in the room?" So it's very important. I agree with you. All right, now we're going to do some fun get to know you questions. So you speak four languages. I'm what I call an arrogant American. I speak one. So you speak Bulgarian, Italian, Spanish, and English. I'm curious, which one was the hardest to learn?


[49:08] Polina Nyer: Yeah, I'm going to begin by saying that I did not plan on speaking four languages. It's just life happened and I do now, which I'm very grateful for. But I would say the hardest for me to learn was Italian, and it has nothing to do with the language. It just has to do with the experience that I had because I went to school in the north of Italy in university, and I was only in Italy for a year when I enrolled. And back then, I'm talking many, many years ago, English undergraduate degrees were not a thing in Italy. So if you wanted a university degree, it had to be in Italian. And I remember my very first class that I attended was private law, and I sat in that room, and this is not a joke, I sat and I did not understand a single word of the first lecture.


[50:06] Polina Nyer: And I remember thinking, how am I ever going to pass this exam, let alone graduate with a university degree? And I must say that this experience just taught me that you don't need to feel very capable of achieving something on the first day. So sometimes you just need to keep showing up and be there, learn, and with time and a lot of dedication and persistence, it will happen for you. But yeah, it has been easier after that language.


[50:43] Paul Barnhurst: Mad respect to you for sticking it out. I would've been like, "I'm done. I can't do it." So I appreciate you sharing that. I imagine there were some days where it's just like, "Can I do this?" But I love that you stuck it out, you made it work, and it sounds like the languages have got a little easier after that. All right, next question. I know you're a big believer in giving back to the community. I've seen some things about that. I know you appreciate volunteering. Favorite story, favorite experience from your volunteering experiences?


[51:16] Polina Nyer: Yeah, I'm very passionate about that, and stop me if I'm talking too much, but my biggest passion is in youth education, and it's very dear to my heart girls' education and helping them not only see the opportunities that they have ahead of them, but also having the confidence to go forward and pursue those opportunities. I participate as a mentor in a program called Technovation Girls, which gathers teams of girls between the ages of eight and 12, and they work together on solving a community problem in their own world. So they pick the problem and they use technology to solve that. So sometimes they code an app, sometimes they build a website, and it's just so fascinating guiding them through that journey. What I help them the most with is they have to build a pitch. So they pitch their ideas as if they were pitching it to investors at the end of the program.


[52:23] Polina Nyer: And this is something that gives me tremendous joy, and I look forward to every single year when the program is restarting. So I do that a lot. And I'm also, recently, I got involved with, I don't know if you've heard of this organization, Junior Achievement.


[52:39] Paul Barnhurst: I've done Junior Achievement. That's a great program.


[52:43] Polina Nyer: Just for the listeners, they do elementary, middle, and high school students, but development of financial literacy. So if someone who works in finance and knows the value of that knowledge, it is a great way to share with the communities and start kids learning early about things like financial planning and personal finances, budgeting. And it is the questions they ask is just the best part.


[53:16] Paul Barnhurst: Especially the elementary kids. I'm totally with you. I can tell you love serving, your eyes lit up, you got very excited. There was more passion as you shared the examples, and so I love that. I mean, there's nothing better than knowing you made a difference for somebody at the end of the day. I mean, we talk FP&A and yes, careers are important and we want to be happy, but how much money we helped our company make in the big scheme of things, it doesn't really matter in a lot of ways.


[53:46] Polina Nyer: Yeah, agree.


[53:46] Paul Barnhurst: In the moment, it feels like it matters a lot when we look back. So I appreciate you sharing that and just kind of opening up about that. Love that. So I think we're going to go ahead and end here and wrap up. We've been going almost an hour. So any last thoughts that you want to share, contact information, anything as far as a wrap up that you'd love to share with the audience?


[54:10] Polina Nyer: Sure. You can contact me on LinkedIn. I share some of my learnings from the practical use cases that I do from AI. And I want to thank you, Paul, for having me on the podcast. It's been great, and I am very happy to be part of this community.


[54:28] Paul Barnhurst: No, thank you. I'm grateful you came on. I'm grateful we were able to connect. I found you from something you shared on LinkedIn, and really glad you came on the show. So thank you for carving out an hour of your time. Appreciate it. That's it for today's episode of FP&A Unlocked. If you enjoy FP&A Unlocked, please take a moment to leave a five-star rating and review. It's the best way to support the FP&A Guy and help more FP&A professionals discover the show. Remember, you can earn CPE credit for this episode by visiting earmarkcpe.com, downloading the app and completing the quiz. If you need continuing education credits for the FPAC certification, complete the quiz and reach out to me directly. Thanks for listening. I'm Paul Barnhurst, the FP&A Guy, and I'll see you next time.



Next
Next

Systems Thinking for FP&A: Three Ways to Improve Planning with Daniel Bryan